Phantom energy: New report exposes empty promises behind nuclear power and data centres
The push for nuclear-powered data centres is entirely dependent on technology that remains commercially unproven and prohibitively expensive, a new report finds.
Coal and gas corporations should be banned from buying offsets as a means of complying with Australia’s climate laws, the Australian Conservation Foundation said as it released new research showing offsets are not delivering claimed benefits.
The research, by academics Andrew Macintosh, Don Butler, Deb Wilkinson, Megan Evans and others, assessed 50 Human Induced Regeneration (HIR) projects and found:
After accounting for facilities entering and exiting the scheme, total emissions from the safeguard mechanism fell by just 0.4% in 2023-24 and 2024-25.
“The safeguard mechanism, Australia’s climate law, is meant to cut climate pollution and protect us from big coal and gas threatening our lives and livelihoods, but it’s not working,” said ACF’s CEO Adam Bandt.
“Putting more climate pollution into the atmosphere now could push us past dangerous tipping points. It can’t be offset, and the science tells us to keep coal and gas in the ground.
“Not only does the offset scam allow unlimited coal and gas expansion in a climate emergency, but in many cases these offsets don’t even do anything good for the environment.
“This research documents invisible forests, trees that should have grown over the last decade because coal and gas have purchased credits to supposedly offset their pollution, but satellite images and ground-truthing reveal virtually unchanged landscapes.
“Coal and gas corporations are gaming the system and they should be banned from buying offsets. They should be forced to stop expanding and actually cut their pollution.
“Dodgy offsets are allowing big coal and gas polluters to cook the books while they cook the planet.
“There are big new coal and gas projects in the pipeline and unless our climate laws are fixed, they’ll be allowed to proceed.”
Woodside has indicated it expects to surrender at least 50 million carbon credits to offset its Browse project, which proposes to drill for gas at Scott Reef and send the gas to the NW Shelf through a 900km underwater pipeline before exporting it.
If Woodside’s Browse gas drilling goes ahead, it would release around 1.6 billion tonnes of climate-heating emissions – nearly four times Australia’s annual emissions.
Carbon offsets generated through the discredited Human Induced Regeneration (HIR) method are Australia’s most used offset, representing 32% of all carbon credit units ever issued, the research shows.
New HIR projects have now been blocked from the carbon credit scheme, but existing projects will continue to generate large numbers of credits for years to come.
Read the research and appendices